Comparing our criminal records policy with five US states

It is clear that criminal record disclosure requirements in England and Wales are much more punitive than the five U.S. states we have researched.

One in six people in England and Wales have a criminal record. But 27% of UK employers wouldn’t hire someone with a conviction.

Criminal records checks are requested by employers as part of the recruitment process and these checks reveal offences and sentences, from prison sentences to police warnings for minor crimes. Employment is a key factor in preventing future offending. But people with criminal records are often trapped in the past, unable to find stable work and contribute their talents to society because of their record.

Other countries, like the US, have begun taking steps to solve the issue and help people with criminal records into employment by changing what is revealed on checks and for how long. So how do we compare?

On behalf of the FairChecks campaign, researchers at Reed Smith LLP have compared what appears on criminal record checks in England and Wales and five US states: California, Connecticut, Utah, New Jersey, and Oklahoma. The information listed on criminal record checks depends on the type of offence someone has committed and the type of check a job is eligible for. Therefore, to get a clear and comparable view of each system, researchers explored the criminal record implications of five specific scenarios in each jurisdiction.

In three out of five scenarios, the England and Wales system is more punitive than any of the five US states. In the other two scenarios, the England and Wales system is similarly punitive to certain states, and more punitive than others.

Researchers from Reed Smith LLP concluded: “It is clear that criminal record disclosure requirements in England and Wales are much more punitive than the five U.S. states we have researched. In Oklahoma, Utah and New Jersey, convictions can often be expunged or pardoned, meaning that a background check will not reveal them.

“In other states, such as California and Connecticut, employers cannot access information on childhood convictions and many offences are sealed automatically so that employers cannot see them. This allows individuals with past convictions a degree of comfort in knowing that future career prospects will not be hindered by the past. Neither position is replicated in England and Wales.”

What does this look like in real terms?

 

One of the scenarios explored in the report is Rich’s story. Rich was convicted of drug possession 12 years ago. In all five US states explored, he can delete the conviction from his record after a maximum of 10 years and move on with his life.

In England and Wales, Rich’s conviction will show for the rest of his life on the detailed checks required for many roles such as teacher, nurse, accountant, or taxi driver. He will constantly face the fear, and very real prospect, that employers will discriminate against him based on his record.

What needs to change?

 

People with criminal records need a fair chance to fulfil their potential. FairChecks is calling for a full review of the criminal records disclosure system in England and Wales.

In the short-term, FairChecks has three stepping stone policy recommendations which would free thousands of people from the enduring impact of a criminal record:

  1. Wipe the slate clean for childhood offences
  2. Remove cautions from criminal record checks
  3. Stop revealing short prison sentences forever

Read the full report below and join FairChecks to help take action towards a fairer system!

More updates

Our criminal records system cost my husband his life
Angry texts to a cheating partner sent my husband’s life on a downward spiral that resulted in his...
Comparing our criminal records policy with five US states
"Our criminal record disclosure requirements are much more punitive than the five U.S. states we researched"
We've moved on, why can't the system?
I’m a happily married mum of 8 and I can’t even visit the elderly because of a caution...

Don’t miss out –
sign up for updates

Sign up to our mailing list for opportunities to take action, share your story, or simply stay up to date.

Skip to content